Skip to main content

Retail Store, Wholesale

Cooperstown Cheese Company


3941 State Highway 28
Milford, NY 13807 Corner of Oxbow Road Otsego County


Monday - Sunday 10am-6pm - Closed January - March



Business owner

Owners - Sharon Tomaselli & Bob Sweitzer Store Manger - Don Evans

Web & Social

We are nationally recognized cheese makers with 2 American Cheese Society awards. We have samples of these cheeses, Jersey Girl and Toma Celena,  along with all the other cheeses we make, in our store for you to try. We do make European style cheeses like Gouda and cheddar but most are our own recipes and can’t be found anywhere else.  In addition to cheese, we have Don’s famous cheesecake in our store. People travel from distant states to get Don’s cheesecake. He makes it plain, or with strawberries, blueberries, or swirled with chocolate.  He also makes pumpkin and eggnog on request. You can have a slice or a full cheese cake.


Farm Products

  • Cheese
  • pastured pork and beef from Upstate Creations

Growing Practices

  • Antibiotic-free

Activities and Services

  • Groups welcome

Wholesale Products

We sell our cheese primarily through wholesale distribution. Please call or email for product description and pricing. We deliver to the metropolitan NYC area and ship via UPS if required.